Five canning fruit growers face contract gap at harvest
Five canning fruit producers lack final Premier contracts as apricot harvesting begins, leaving delivery volumes, prices and the full extent of legal liabilities exposed.
- Entered
- Plot
- 1.8 ha
- Record
- 719 words
- Walk-through
- 4 min
DrillSprayHarvestPlanning window

Agronomist’s notes
- Premier took control of the Tulbagh plant in March 2026 after a R5,7 billion merger with Rhodes Food Group.
- Five canning fruit producers are pursuing legal action against Premier.
- The original contracts required a two-year notice period for termination.
- A proposed settlement would apply the original contract terms for this season before sending the dispute to arbitration.
- The Competition Commission is considering revoking the merger approval or imposing amended conditions.
By Daniel Okafor
Five canning-fruit producers face an unresolved contract dispute as the apricot harvest begins, with no alternative Premier contracts issued to the growers involved.
Premier took full control of the Tulbagh processing facility in March 2026 after acquiring Rhodes Food Group in a R5,7 billion merger deal. Before the takeover, participating farmers held long-term rolling contracts with Rhodes, meaning terms continued on a rolling basis rather than ending after one season.
The original contracts required a two-year notice period for termination. That period contrasts with Premier’s present demand: growers must surrender all contractual rights and claims to have their fruit received this season.
Can a settlement preserve this season’s supply?
The five producers pursuing legal action want Premier to honour their original long-term rolling contracts. Under a proposal on the table, Premier would apply those terms for this season, after which the parties would refer the dispute to arbitration, a private dispute-resolution process.
Jacques Jordaan, CEO of the Canning Fruit Producers’ Association, said: “If finalised, this agreement might eliminate the need for these producers to return to court and allow them to continue supplying their fruit as stipulated in their original contracts for at least this season.”
That arrangement would restore the contracted terms during the immediate harvest while leaving the longer-term relationship for arbitration. If the parties fail to agree, however, the interdict hearing will proceed.
What happens under Premier’s alternative offer?
Premier has agreed to receive fruit from the remaining producers for this season, but requires them to give up all contractual rights and claims. It also denies them the option of arbitration.
The season therefore faces two contractual tiers. Five producers could receive their original terms if they accept the settlement proposal; the rest would have current-season delivery in exchange for a complete waiver of claims.
Jordaan said the apricot harvest had started that week, yet producers still had no alternative contracts from Premier. They faced the prospect of harvesting crops over the coming weeks without valid agreements in place.
That uncertainty extends to three operating decisions:
- The exact volume of fruit growers can deliver;
- The price they will receive;
- The full extent of their legal liabilities.
Without settled terms, a grower cannot treat the factory gate as a secure outlet. The field decision to pick fruit now carries commercial risk that the original contracts were supposed to allocate over a much longer period.
Why has Tulbagh closed?
Premier says closure of the Tulbagh plant was necessary because of tough global market conditions and a worsening operating environment since the takeover. In interim results for the six months ended September, published earlier that month, Premier said the closure bore no relation to the merger.
The company also points to support it has provided growers. Premier says it reached settlement agreements covering removal of some orchards, committed to paying for fruit harvested this season, and made the Tulbagh factory available for new job-creating ventures.
The association disputes that presentation. It says growers initially received assurances that Premier’s acquisition would change nothing, only to hear that the company would take no canning fruit for the season. It also faced last-minute settlement deadlines as harvest approached.
The association called Premier’s conduct “commercially oppressive” and warned: “Premier presents these arrangements as support for farmers, but does not explain the rights they must surrender. That gives the public an incomplete picture.”
Its central demand is straightforward: Premier should make workable arrangements for the current harvest without requiring growers to abandon future rights.
Can regulators change the outcome?
The Competition Commission is considering revoking the merger approval or imposing amended conditions. Premier has dismissed the likelihood of the Competition Appeal Court undoing the transaction and says no party contemplated closing Tulbagh before approval.
Regulatory scrutiny may widen the dispute, but it does not itself give growers settled delivery volumes or prices for the fruit now coming in. The practical focus remains the settlement proposal and the interdict hearing, both of which require decisions before more of the crop reaches the field.
Growers should watch for a final response to the five-producer proposal, clarity on whether arbitration survives any broader settlement, and the terms attached to Premier’s acceptance of fruit from the remaining producers.
via Farmers Weekly South Africa (Source)
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Market editor covering money, funding and market shifts around production farming and field operations at Arable Wire.
199 articles
Nearby records
- BG 35SA cherry crop jumps 111%, but China access stalls and shelf life shrinksOctober 28, 2026
- JP 66AgWest Enters Creditor Protection as Farm Equipment Dealer Stress DeepensOctober 20, 2026
- WG 85John Deere settlement puts farmers at cash-versus-repair crossroadsOctober 10, 2026
- CZ 50UK cereal yields fall below historic averages, AHDB final report confirmsOctober 20, 2026
- RT 73EU Council Caps Pesticide Approvals at 15 Years, Rejects Open-Ended RenewalsOctober 1, 2026